Second Homes

A Fire Island beach house for $1.1 million with a vintage vibe

By Rebecca Fishbein | June 22, 2018 - 12:00PM 

The house was built in 1937 and has been renovated.

Douglas Elliman

Fire Island has long been a beloved summer getaway for New Yorkers. The 9.6-square-mile barrier island, off Long Island's Suffolk County, offers pristine (occasionally nude) beaches, rollicking nightlife, a thriving LGBTQ scene (particularly in the towns of Cherry Grove and Fire Island Pines), and car-free streets for biking, running, and strolling barefoot, should you choose. 

There's also a slew of good real estate on the island, provided you stock up on flood insurance. Fire Island Pines, for instance, features a number of gorgeous modernist houses, as does the party-happy village of Ocean Beach. Other residential options include vintage bungalows, condos, and pool-outfitted beach homes for summer visitors and year-round residents alike. You have to have some decent cash to own property on the island, with median listing prices in popular villages climbing over $1 million.

But if that's feasible for you, there are beautiful houses to be had, like this three bedroom, two-bath house at 170 Wilmot Road in Ocean Beach, now on the market for $1,100,000. The house was built in 1937 and has been newly renovated, and is about a block from the bay. 

The house has a light-filled living room, with an impressive ceiling with wood paneling and exposed wooden beams, and oak floors, evoking a true vintage beach-bungalow vibe. The wagon wheel light fixture is a nice touch, too.

There's access to a porch off the dining room via a glass sliding door, which probably makes for some lovely sunlit breakfasts. 

The stone-finished kitchen has been outfitted with modern Samsung stainless steel appliances, and Maplewood cabinets that match the wood-paneled ceiling. 

The window-filled master bedroom has room for a king-sized bed and a desk, and there's an en-suite bathroom.

The bathroom's got an inviting-looking custom glass shower.

There are two additional cozy bedrooms, for children or for guests.

But the property's best feature is its outdoor space, as is befitting a summer beach house. There is, for instance, this outdoor deck for lounging and sunbathing.

When the sun's too strong, or in a storm, you can retreat to the enclosed porch.

There's another deck with room for a second dining table and chairs.

And there's even an outdoor shower house, so you can de-sand your feet post-beach.

To get to Ocean Beach from the city, you can take the Long Island Rail Road from Penn Station to Bay Shore station and a cab to the Fire Island Ferries (instructions here.) Note that Ocean Beach is a car-free village. The whole trip takes a little over two hours.


Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.