What property managers wish new NYC co-op or condo board members understood
- A property manager can’t make decisions for you but will explain how the building works
- Your role as board members is to serve the entire building, not just shepherd a pet project
New board members often think problems have simple solutions but that’s rarely the case.
iStock
Owners and shareholders are often motivated to join their New York City co-op or condo board because of an unresolved building problem, rising maintenance, or issues with management. Whatever brings someone to the board, it’s likely that what follows is a steep learning curve; board operations involve a complex set of responsibilities and every building has shifting legal and financial priorities as well as a variety of capital needs.
If your building has a property manager, it’s their role to advise and implement the board’s decisions but that doesn’t replace the board’s responsibility to govern. The board still needs to make decisions and follow the procedures outlined in the governing documents.
“It’s a business,” said Mark Levine, principal at the property management firm EBMG. “A lot of board members forget they are running a business.”
To set you up for running a business with your neighbors in your spare time, property managers weighed in with some advice.
The answers are in the governing documents
Like any corporation or business, a co-op or condo building has a framework of rules by which it operates. These are the governing documents and bylaws. Granted, it may not be the most enticing read, but the bylaws give you a better understanding of your role and responsibilities. They help you understand the relationship between the board and shareholders or unit owners.
“You need to understand what the allowances are for the board to act on their own, what they can change, implement and decide on," Levine said. “But also where the board has to go out to the shareholders or unit owners for approval.”
Seeking approval from shareholders or unit owners could be required if you want to initiate a flip tax in the building or if there’s an expenditure over a certain dollar amount.
Figuring out how the building operates also involves understanding the building’s finances, history, and existing problems.
Gaps in those documents are the board’s responsibility
There are often gaps in the governing documents and the board needs to make decisions to fill them. “It is not a static environment,” said Kyle Gregory, operating partner at New Way Property Management. “If your co-op was built in 1984, how could anyone have contemplated the implications of an HVAC split system?”
Boards need to make all sorts of decisions against a constantly changing backdrop of government regulations, rising costs, insurance pressures, and technological advances. “There are inherent and intentional undefined spaces that you are meant to review with regularity and come up with opinions on, in service of the greater good of the building,” Gregory said.
One common misunderstanding is about the role of management. “The board makes the decisions and the manager carries them out,” said Aaron Weber, property manager and partner at Weber Realty Management. Your property manager can’t make decisions for your board but can help by giving a full overview of how the building works. “Document every decision in the minutes and ask questions, because nothing is too basic in your first year,” Weber said.
Board governance is a team sport
It’s important to understand the roles of board members. Each member has a vote and while the board president will take the reins on occassion, “they help to run the meeting and [set] the agenda, but they don't have more power than anybody else,” Levine said. Like all board members, they have just one vote.
Volunteers to the board need to know the job is to serve the entire building. “It shouldn’t be rooted in an underlying personal desire,” Gregory said. The work, after all, is complicated. “Operating real estate is difficult—try to educate yourself to the best of your ability so you can be a useful and productive team mate in solving problems for your building,” he said.
The same advice was echoed by Evangelos Fantakos, managing member at Highrise Property Management. “The best boards aren't necessarily the ones with the most experience,” he said. “They're the ones that can put personal opinions aside, make decisions collectively and recognize that running a building requires a team effort.”
And all teams have auxiliary staff. “Take care of your super,” Weber said.
Plan for the long term
Very often new board members are certain there is a simple fix to a problem they’ve identified. Most of the time that’s not the case. “Think long term,” Gregory said. “The ethos of year one should be: let’s patiently explore all of the positive and negative workings of the building and discern what deserves our attention.”
Sometimes you will need to make unpopular decisions, like raising maintenance. Weber’s recommendation is to have a five- to 10-year capital plan and fund the building’s reserves based on it.
“No one wants to pay increased common charges or assessments but it’s important to understand where the charges come from in the border context of operating the property,” Gregory said.
Many property managers caution against being penny wise and pound foolish. “Bid out major work and compare scopes, not just prices,” Weber said. “And fix small problems before they become big ones.”
Fantakos pointed out buildings don’t become less expensive to maintain with age. “I tell boards that choosing the cheapest contractor can sometimes turn out to be the most expensive decision they make,” he said.
The next board will benefit from your attention to detail
In most corporations, changes in leadership don't necessarily mean the loss of institutional knowledge. In co-ops and condos, however, when board members leave they often take valuable knowledge and context with them.
This increases the importance of archiving decisions and having a system for documenting and storing information. “It would be helpful if any future board had the full context of all the decisions that were made up to that point,” Levine said.
He also stressed the importance of following a code of conduct and code of confidentiality to reduce liability while on the board. This includes establishing how the board will communicate. “We want the protection of the corporation and directors and officers (D&O) insurance to kick in if there’s a lawsuit,” Levine said. D&O insurance protects board members who are sued over decisions made in good faith. “Putting yourself out there with a risk is not worth it,” he added.
You Might Also Like

