Would You Rather?

It's spring: Time for New Yorkers to tell us their favorite type of outdoor space

By Lambeth Hochwald | May 8, 2017 - 9:59AM 

When it comes to finding a dream New York City pad, an outdoor space is pretty much a unicorn when it comes to add-on features. In fact, for many, the idea of stepping outside for a cup of morning coffee—in your PJs—seems too dreamy for city living. While we’re dreaming, which would we prefer: a backyard for barbecuing, a balcony for twilight cocktails, or a roof deck to gaze at the skyline and stars? Let our New Yorkers tell you what they wish for:

Romeo Romeo I’d much prefer a balcony to a backyard. It might be smaller than a backyard, but a balcony becomes an extension of your apartment, giving the illusion of more square footage and it feels more intimate and offers more privacy. And I get the feeling that a backyard takes more maintenance than a balcony (not to mention potential critters!). —Denise, Upper East Side

Room with a view I would love to have a balcony. What better way to spend summer mornings than being about to enjoy a view with a coffee in hand. —Kevin, Jackson Heights, Queens

I’m here for the views I moved from Ohio almost three years ago now. I am currently apartment-hunting for the second time and I’d love a roof deck. My current place has a sketchy ladder that goes to the roof so a real one would be amazing. —Chelsea, Bushwick, Brooklyn (pictured below)

Give me a backyard I’ve had all three. Roof decks are great but you tend to look down, so I chose a place with a backyard so I can look up and see the possibilities. —Ilene, Upper West Side

Morning music I love living in the village and dream of having a backyard. There’s nothing like being outside for morning quiet time and a coffee (or two) for lyric writing and playing a little acoustic guitar (softly, so I don't disturb the neighbors). —Kate, West Village

Verdict: A tie for balcony and backyard with a single vote for a soaring roof deck!

Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.
topics: