Rent Coach

Rent Coach: I broke my lease, found someone to replace me and my ex-landlord is still holding my deposit. What gives?

By Mike Akerly  | January 31, 2013 - 12:31PM

Q. Last month I decided to move in to my boyfriend’s two-bedroom apartment and give up my own studio.  I still had about eight months left on the lease, but the landlord agreed to allow me to assign it to a new tenant. 

I found someone to take over the lease and they moved in last week, but now my landlord said he won’t return my security deposit for another eight months (when my lease would have ended).  How can he do that?

A. Entering into a lease agreement is a serious matter, and the legal rules that pertain to releasing one of the parties to the agreement from their obligations can be complicated.  You stated that you “assigned” the lease to a new tenant; however, without reading the terms of the agreement, it’s not possible to know what exactly happened.

An assignment is when you transfer all of your remaining interest in a lease to someone else.  For example, if you had eight months remaining on your lease and granted all of that time to the new tenant (the assignee) that would be an assignment.  This is different than a sub-lease, in which you grant less than all of your rights to the lease and maintain some right of reversion (i.e. a right to retake the premises at some point in the future during the course of your lease). 

Things can get even trickier from here.  Technically, an assignment is a contract between you and the new tenant.  The landlord is not involved.  From that come a number of consequences.  First, the new tenant (the assignee) is not directly responsible to your landlord but rather to you.  That fact can be changed if the new tenant also signs an assumption agreement, under which they assume all of your obligations pursuant to your lease with the landlord. 

Moreover, simply assigning your lease to a third party, even if that party enters into an assumption agreement with you, does not mean that you are released from your obligations to the landlord.  The only way to that is to also obtain a written release from the landlord stating that you are no longer liable for the apartment once the lease has been assigned to the new tenant and that tenant also enters into an assumption agreement.

That is why, without reading the documents that were used to “assign” your lease to a new tenant, it’s not possible to say for sure what you agreed to.  However, if you did not receive a release, you are still liable to the landlord in the event that the new tenant defaults. Because of that, absent a written agreement to the contrary, the landlord can keep your security deposit until you are no longer liable for the lease.

It’s not uncommon, however, for a tenant to negotiate with the landlord for the return of the security deposit if the new tenant replaces it with a deposit of their own.  In that case, your landlord would not be able to keep your deposit for another eight months. 

Mike Akerly is a New York City real estate attorney, landlord, and real estate broker. He is also the publisher of the Greenwich Village blog VillageConfidential.     

Note: The information provided here is for informational purposes only. It should not be construed as legal advice and cannot substitute for the advice of a licensed professional applying their specialized knowledge to the particular circumstances of your case.

See all Rent Coach.

Related posts:

Renting advice from the master

Read this before moving near THAT

Rent Coach: Fair and foul play with security deposits

Rent Coach: Can a landlord ask for two months' security deposit?

Rent Coach: Do I really have to renew my lease two months early?



Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.