Skip to main content
Fulltext search
FILTER RESULTS BY:
RECOMMENDED IN RENT
Moving to NYC after college? Here's how to find a rental apartment
RECOMMENDED IN BUY
How buying real estate in NYC is unlike anywhere else
RECOMMENDED IN SELL
A guide to using a no-fee renovation loan from a NYC real estate firm
RECOMMENDED IN IMPROVE
How to make your NYC renovation more pet-friendly
BEST REAL ESTATE WEBSITE!
National Association of Real Estate Editors
BEST REAL ESTATE WEBSITE! National Association of Real Estate Editors
Brick Underground
Social Links
follow:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Flipboard
  • search
Brick Underground
☰ Brick Underground
Brick Underground
Brick Underground
☰
Brick Underground
  • Buy
    • Buy
    • The Market
    • Investing
    • New Construction + Condos
    • Affordable Housing
    • Co-ops
    • Negotiating + Financing
    • How to Buy in NYC Guide
    A rendering of the roofdeck at 55 Broad Street.
    Rent
    Housing lottery launches for 143 apartments in the Financial District
    Aerial panoramic view of Red Hook, Staten Island, Brooklyn, and Verrazano-Narrows Bridge
    Sales Market
    24 NYC neighborhoods where median prices more than doubled in the past decade
    431 West 54th Street is a co-op building that allows subletting.
    Investing
    Want to buy an investment apartment to rent out? Here's what you need to know
  • Rent
    • Rent
    • Affordable Housing
    • Roommates + Landlords
    • The Market
    • The Search
    • How to Rent in NYC Guide
    Young woman using laptop at new apartment, with moving boxes around.
    Roommates + Landlords
    Didn't get your security deposit returned in NYC? A new chatbot can help
    A rendering of the six-story building in Park Slope.
    Affordable Housing
    Housing lottery launches for 45 rent-stabilized units in Park Slope
    Laura and her dog Jack
    Rent
    Why I moved to NYC from Brazil: I relocated for work and reunited with friends I made 15 years ago
  • Sell
    • Sell
    • Staging + Open Houses
    • Negotiations + Closings
    • Getting Ready
    • How to Sell in NYC Guide
    Aerial view of downtown Brooklyn
    Sell
    Median sales price in Brooklyn climbs to $995,000 in the second quarter
    Downtown New York City
    Sell
    Manhattan deals rose to highest level in nearly two years, defying national trends
    new condo building and older co-op buildings in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn
    Sell
    Brooklyn median price nears $1 million but the spring market is a question mark
  • Live
    • Live
    • Neighbors
    • Kids + Pets
    • Neighborhood Intel
    • Products + Test-drives
    • Troubleshooting
    FlatRate moving brick underground
    Live
    How to troubleshoot your move in advance
    Sponsored By flatrate
    Distressed woman sitting in her apartment
    Troubleshooting
    Ask Altagracia: My live-in partner is abusive. How can I get out of my lease?
    Sponsored By Outerbridge Law P.C.
    NYC apartment buildings with fire escapes
    Neighborhood Intel
    Can you sit on a fire escape in NYC? 5 things to know
  • Improve
    • Improve
    • Small Spaces
    • Small Projects + DIY
    • Renovations
    • Design + Architecture
    • Products + Services
    • How to Renovate in NYC Guide
    mini splits apartments new york city
    Products + Services
    Yes, you can install central AC in your co-op or condo unit. Here's how
    image
    Products + Services
    Take back your deck! How to win the war with mosquitoes and enjoy outdoor living again
    NYC apartment building with AC units
    Products + Services
    My neighbor's dripping AC is driving me crazy. What can I do?
  • Boards & Buildings
    • Boards & Buildings
    • Boards
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Property Management
    • Structure & Systems
    • Sustainability
    Burned and Boarded Up Windows
    When should your board hire a public adjuster?
    Manhattan GM
    What should we consider when renewing insurance for our building?
    Facade of NYC buildings
    How much is insurance on a NYC co-op or condo building?
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with us
    • Sponsored Content
    • Experts
    FlatRate moving brick underground
    Live
    How to troubleshoot your move in advance
    Sponsored By flatrate
    Distressed woman sitting in her apartment
    Troubleshooting
    Ask Altagracia: My live-in partner is abusive. How can I get out of my lease?
    Sponsored By Outerbridge Law P.C.
    Building facades in New York in winter
    Roommates + Landlords
    Ask Altagracia: I withheld rent due to inadequate heat and I'm being hassled to pay it back. What should I do?
    Sponsored By Outerbridge Law P.C.
  • Brick Report
  • About Us
  • About Us
The subscription service is currently unavailable. Please check again later.
Fulltext search
FILTER RESULTS BY:
New Main menu
  • Buy
    • Buy
    • The Market
    • Investing
    • New Construction + Condos
    • Affordable Housing
    • Co-ops
    • Negotiating + Financing
    • How to Buy in NYC Guide
  • Rent
    • Rent
    • Affordable Housing
    • Roommates + Landlords
    • The Market
    • The Search
    • How to Rent in NYC Guide
  • Sell
    • Sell
    • Staging + Open Houses
    • Negotiations + Closings
    • Getting Ready
    • How to Sell in NYC Guide
  • Live
    • Live
    • Neighbors
    • Kids + Pets
    • Neighborhood Intel
    • Products + Test-drives
    • Troubleshooting
  • Improve
    • Improve
    • Small Spaces
    • Small Projects + DIY
    • Renovations
    • Design + Architecture
    • Products + Services
    • How to Renovate in NYC Guide
  • Boards & Buildings
    • Boards & Buildings
    • Boards
    • Finance
    • Insurance
    • Legal
    • Property Management
    • Structure & Systems
    • Sustainability
  • Advertise
    • Advertise with us
    • Sponsored Content
    • Experts
  • Brick Report
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Advertise
  • About Us
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER →
Social Links Footer
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Search
Ask Altagracia [ SPONSORED ]

Ask Sam: A new twist in a fight against a landlord who tenants say illegally de-regulated their apartments

  • The case concerns how to calculate the legal regulated rent and rent overcharges for about 78 apartments
  • Apartments were illegally destabilized while the building's owner received J-51 tax benefits
By Himmelstein McConnell Gribben & Joseph LLP  | April 12, 2023 - 12:30PM
image of New York City apartment buildings

“This case flows from the Roberts decision in 2009, which held that apartments in buildings that received J-51 benefits and were deregulated after the benefits expired, in fact remained rent stabilized,” attorney Sam Himmelstein says.

James Andrews via Getty Images

SHARE:
Share to Facebook
Share to Twitter
Print
More...

A new ruling from the New York State Court of Appeals will affect the way rent is calculated for a group of rent-stabilized tenants in a building where the landlord received J-51 tax abatements and illegally de-regulated the apartments.

“This case flows from the Roberts decision in 2009, which held that apartments in buildings that received J-51 benefits and were deregulated after the benefits expired, in fact remained rent stabilized,” says Sam Himmelstein, an attorney at Himmelstein McConnell Gribben & Joseph who represents residential and commercial tenants and tenant associations. “As a result of that ruling, our firm was retained by several tenant associations to pursue class action lawsuits against landlords who deregulated apartments.”

The case in question concerned how to calculate the legal regulated rent, and rent overcharges, for approximately 78 apartments that were illegally destabilized while the building was receiving J-51 tax benefits.

“The lawsuit was filed in October 2011. After the lawsuit was filed, the landlord engaged in what we described as egregious conduct,” says Ronald Languedoc, an attorney at HMGJ. “The landlord contacted many of these tenants individually and told them they had recalculated their rent, and their legal rents were much higher than what they had been charged. In some cases it was double or triple what they were paying.”

In 2017, the State Supreme Court ruled in the tenants’ favor. By falsely recalculating the rents after the lawsuit was filed, the landlord had engaged in an en masse scheme intended to defraud the tenants, the ruling stated.

“Because of the landlord’s conduct, the Supreme Court held that the default formula should be applied for each of these apartments,” Languedoc says. “The default formula is a method for calculating legal rents when there has been a fraudulent scheme or no adequate rental history records are available.”

The landlord appealed the decision to the Appellate Division, and, in 2021, the tenants prevailed. However, the landlord was granted a second appeal, to the Court of Appeals, the highest Court in New York State. On this second appeal, the landlord’s attorneys raised the issue of whether the en masse improper recalculation of the rents required the application of the default formula, where there were, in many cases, records showing what was actually charged.   

Under the applicable law, there was a so-called “base date” rule: When an apartment was illegally deregulated, the courts could only look at rental records from four years prior to when a lawsuit was filed—even if the apartment was deregulated before that date. The legal rent for the apartment would then be calculated based on whatever the rent was four years before. (The Rent Stabilization Law was amended in 2019 to eliminate the base-date rule, but the prior law applies in this case because the lawsuit was filed before 2019.)

There was an exception, though, for fraud: if an apartment was deregulated in a fraudulent scheme, the courts would apply the default formula to determine the new legal rent, rather than use the four-year rule.

“The point raised by the landlord’s attorneys was that the egregious recalculation of the rents took place after the four-year base date, and in many cases, records existed showing the actual rent charged on the base date. Therefore, the landlord’s attorneys argued that the recalculation of the rents could be disregarded, and the Court could set the base date rent based upon records showing what was actually charged at that time.”

The Court of Appeals agreed with the landlord’s position, and determined that the recalculated rents could be disregarded, and the legal rent could be calculated pursuant to records showing what was actually charged on the base date.

For the tenants, this means that the case will now be remanded to the trial court level, in order to look at each apartment on a case-by-case basis to determine whether or not there are adequate rental records to calculate the new legal rents.

This ruling is fairly narrow, Languedoc says, and should not impact how future courts determine whether a landlord has conducted a fraudulent scheme.

For tenants who suspect their apartments have been illegally deregulated, “they have the right to investigate that base date rent,” Languedoc says. “A lease might look credible on its face, but the tenant has right to investigate on their own or with an attorney to confirm whether that’s really the case or not.”

Related: 

Ask Sam: My landlord claims I'm not rent-stabilized because a J-51 subsidy expired before I moved in. Is this true? (sponsored) 

Ask Sam: How do I find out if my apartment should be rent-stabilized—and if the landlord owes me money? (sponsored)

Ask Sam: I found out my apartment used to be rent-stabilized. Now what? (sponsored)

Read all our Ask a Renters Rights Lawyer columns here.


Sam Himmelstein, Esq. represents NYC tenants and tenant associations in disputes over evictions, rent increases, rental conversions, rent stabilization law, lease buyouts, and many other issues. He is a partner at Himmelstein, McConnell, Gribben & Joseph in Manhattan. To submit a question for this column, click here. To ask about a legal consultation, email Sam or call (212) 349-3000.

Alanna Schubach

Alanna Schubach

Contributing writer

Contributing editor Alanna Schubach has over a decade of experience as a New York City-based freelance journalist.

SEE MORE BY Alanna Schubach »
Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.

topics:

Ask Altagracia landlords leases rent laws rent regulation taxes tenants
SHARE
TWEET
BRICK’S PICKS
NYC apartment building with AC units
My neighbor's dripping AC is driving me crazy. What can I do?
Historic brick facades of NYC apartment buildings
Getting overcharged by a landlord? Here’s how the Tenant Protection Unit helps rent-stabilized tenants
Apartment buildings in Soho
New Rent Guidelines Board report justifies a rent freeze, tenant advocates claim
Brooklyn apartment buildings
Understanding net effective rent: Here's how to calculate your real monthly rent
image
How much should you renovate your NYC apartment or house before selling?
Council Member Shahana Hanif hold press conference before the City Council vote on Arrow Linen spot rezoning.
City Council signs off on 10-story towers for Arrow Linen site
Follow Brick on Instagram
@brickunderground | #brickunderground
Brick UndergroundBRICK UNDERGROUNDREAL LIFE. REAL ESTATE. REAL NEW YORK.
Social Links Footer
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Search
Main menu footer
  • Buy
    • The Market
    • Investing
    • New Construction + Condos
    • Affordable Housing
    • Co-ops
    • Negotiating + Financing
    • How to Buy in NYC Guide
  • Rent
    • Affordable Housing
    • Roommates + Landlords
    • The Market
    • The Search
    • How to Rent in NYC Guide
  • Sell
    • Staging + Open Houses
    • Negotiations + Closings
    • Getting Ready
    • How to Sell in NYC Guide
  • Live
    • Neighbors
    • Kids + Pets
    • Neighborhood Intel
    • Products + Test-drives
    • Troubleshooting
  • Improve
    • Small Spaces
    • Small Projects + DIY
    • Renovations
    • Design + Architecture
    • Products + Services
    • How to Renovate in NYC Guide

Get more news you can actually use...

Email Address

Delivered to your inbox weekly - for free.

*By signing up you agree to receive occasional emails on behalf of our sponsors

Footer Menu
  • About Us
  • Advertise

Copyright 2009-2024 by BND Ventures Inc | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices | Login