Second Homes

5 beach houses for sale on Fire Island, NY

Austin Havens-Bowen
By Austin Havens-Bowen  |
April 23, 2021 - 12:30PM

This Water Island four bedroom is listed for $1,995,000. 

Fire Island Sales & Rentals

Fire Island, a 31-mile stretch off the South Shore of Long Island, is known for its lively LGBTQ scene, pristine beaches, and for being mostly car-free. It’s also only two hours away from New York City.

It’s made up of 17 towns and villages like Cherry Grove, a popular LGBTQ destination where you’ll find Cherry’s On The Bay, Island Breeze, and Top of the Bay; Fire Island Pines, which surrounds a harbor and has eateries like Canteen and Pines Bistro; and Ocean Beach, the largest village on the island.

When you want to enjoy the outdoors, you can head to public beaches and parks like Barrett Beach Park, Fire Island National Seashore, Great South Beach, Sailors Haven, and Robert Moses State Park. There’s also Fire Island Lighthouse and Watch Hill Campground. 

If you want to buy a house on the island, the current median sales price is $865,000, according to Redfin. Right now, you can find modest beach cottages and multi-million dollar waterfront houses across the barrier island. 

Sound like a fit? Consider these five houses for sale in Fire Island Pines, Cherry Grove, Ocean Beach, Water Island, and Seaview. 

367 Crown Walk, Fire Island Pines

This four bedroom, two bath is listed for $850,000. The house has wood-paneled walls, hardwood floors, high arched ceilings, built-ins, moldings, stainless steel appliances, ceiling fans, and a deck. Sayville Ferry and Pines Pizza are nearby.  

210 West Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove

This four bedroom, two and a half bath is listed for $975,000. It sits on an oversized lot and features a wood-burning fireplace, hardwood floors, several windows, tracking lighting, stainless steel appliances, a sunroom, roof deck, patio, and in-ground pool. Sweet Licks and the Sayville Ferry are nearby. 

305 Cottage Walk, Ocean Beach 

This five bedroom, three and a half bath is listed for $1,499,000. The 1930 house has hardwood floors, crown molding, high ceilings, several windows, an office, covered porch, deck, in-ground pool, and an outdoor bath house. Scoops and Kline’s are nearby. 

2 Spatenga Walk, Water Island

This four bedroom, one and two half bath is listed for $1,995,000. The house has 360-degree ocean views plus vaulted ceilings, oak floors, stainless steel appliances, oversized windows, track lighting, four decks, a laundry room, mudroom, in-ground pool, and docking rights. It’s being offered furnished. Barrett Beach Park is nearby. 

40 Evergreen Ave., Seaview 

This four bedroom, three bath is listed for $2,199,000. The house has high ceilings, hardwood floors, several windows, recessed lighting, stainless steel appliances, a screened-in porch, deck, and outdoor shower. Seaview Boat Basin and Seaview Market are nearby. 


Austin Havens-Bowen

Austin Havens-Bowen


Austin Havens-Bowen is a writer and reporter. He previously covered local news for the Queens Ledger and The Hunts Point Express in the Bronx. He graduated from Hunter College with a BA in media studies. He rents a one-bedroom apartment in Astoria with his boyfriend and their two cats.

Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.