Would You Rather?

Would you rather live in a dark and quiet apartment or a loud and sunny one?

By Mayra David  | July 24, 2013 - 2:56PM

Quiet and dark as a tomb--or as bright and loud as a street fair? We asked five New Yorkers which kind of apartment they'd rather call home, and the answers were nearly unanimous. Seems like city-dwellers really appreciate their peace and quiet.

  • Quiet and dark: I love my apartment. But the bus screeches by and stops just past my window. Loud cars, loud conversation, I hear it all. When I move to my next apartment  I’ll definitely be looking for apartment descriptions like “quiet and cozy” rather than "tons of sun from huge south facing windows," which is what I have now. More window means more street noise. The next apartment should at least have a quiet bedroom. -Alicia, Upper West Side
  • Quiet and dark: In this city, as much quiet as you can get is just more important. You can decorate a dark apartment to feel cozy. But noise is hard to fight.  -Ann Marie, Bronx
  • Quiet and dark: I’d rather sleep soundly than sunbathe in my apartment! I also want as much privacy as possible. So if I can’t hear my neighbors, that means they can’t hear me. -Alvira, Morningside Heights
  • Quiet and dark: I’m in a dark apartment now because I only have one window that faces out on the street, and the others face the back alleyway. I have the quiet zone in my apartment and the loud zone. I definitely prefer the quiet zone. When my roommate and I first moved here, I was a bit bummed she got the light room. Now she’s bummed that she did. - David, Upper West Side
  • Loud and light: Light is life! I have a ton of light now and that means I also have lots of thriving pots of herbs. Every morning I get a dose of Vitamin D and that pretty much guarantees a good day. Sunlight fights depression and who wants to ever be depressed? To me, city sounds are just a natural part of city living! -Alexandra, Harlem

Related posts:

Would you rather...have a two-bathroom apartment or a one-bathroom with a washer-dryer?

Would you rather...live in a fabulous 4th floor walk-up, or a plain-vanilla elevator building abode?

Battle of the outdoor spaces: Backyard/patio vs terrace/roofdeck

An Elevator View of the NYC skyline

Don't know what a lot line window is? You should

Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.