Would You Rather?

Would you rather have a state of the art gym or a gorgeously landscaped roofdeck?

Share this Article

This week we're turning our attention toward building amenities. We asked six New Yorkers whether they'd rather have a state-of-the-art gym in their building or a gorgeous landscaped roof deck? Here's what they had to say:

  • Gym: A gym, of course. Working out is necessary, while sitting around and tanning is actually pretty bad for your health anyway.  -Alyson, Midtown West
  • Gym: A gym because that would (I presume) save me some money on a gym membership. Even if there were a small fee to join one, at least I would be getting something substantial out of it. A roof deck is nice on occassion, I guess. But if you think about it, sitting out on the hot roof of a building sounds pretty awful to me.  And then I wouldn’t even get anything out of it during the colder, wetter seasons -Jim, Chelsea
  • Roofdeck: I’d rather have a roofdeck because I actually like my gym anyway. We have a spa, and having multiple locations is great, too. A roof deck would be a nice bonus, especially if they did it right, with lots of  shaded areas, and if we were allowed to barbeque. -Martin, Harlem
  • Gym: There are plenty of roof top bars around if I want to see a view. -Kelvin, Gramercy
  • A roofdeck ...my way:  I’d love to have a roofdeck that wasn’t landscaped to perfection, but rather one where they give tenants little garden plots. Just a roof deck with lounge chairs is kind of a waste. -Cynthia, Chelsea
  • Gym… ? A gym would be the good for the body and the roof deck would be good for the mind. I’d flip a coin and hope it lands on gym, I guess. -Aguilar, Morningside Heights.

The consensus: Gym 4:, Roof deck: 2. Winner (by a slim margin): Gym!

Related posts:

Would you rather...have a two-bathroom apartment or a one-bathroom with a washer-dryer?

Would you rather...live in a fabulous 4th floor walk-up, or a plain-vanilla elevator building abode?

An Elevator View of the NYC skyline

Don't know what a lot line window is? You should