The Market

To buy or not to buy?

By Margot Slade  | March 16, 2011 - 7:38AM

That is the question prompting a rent-vs-own debate on the NYT CityRoom blog, where Times reporter Christine Haughney suggests the answer varies by the price of real estate in a specific neighborhood. Our reading of the comments so far: Renting beats buying by a comfortable margin.  Here are some arguments on both sides:


  • You don't have to move every 1-2 years, as leases sometimes require. 
  • You can fix up the place as you like. 
  • You can take advantage of mortgage interest and tax payment deductions. 
  • Being an owner among owners brings a sense of community as you see the same people through the years. 
  • Management companies are more responsive to owners.
  • If you can't get hold of a decent rent stabilized apartment, and are in for the long haul, "buying allows you to fix a huge portion of your expenses and makes more sense where costs are comparable. It also lets you keep a foot in the market, which is essential protection if prices increase drastically."
  • "The basic reason for owning ... is control of my home." 


  • "You can always pull up stakes and go to another neighborhood when your present location becomes overdeveloped."
  • The transaction costs of buying and selling in NYC, notably the mortgage recording and transfer tax, make owning a losing proposition investment-wise.
  • Rent in big cities and buy in the country, preferably near weekend getaway spots, usually a better investment, if only for your sanity.
  • "Buying is a great idea--when the numbers make sense. The numbers have not made sense in at least 13 years." 
  • Rent-stabilized tenants cannot lose their tenancy at the landlord's whim.
  • And this from a renter of 40 years: "No one ever told me I could not replace the washer/dryer I had for years. Or that the relative that spends Christmas vacation with me for years was suddenly staying too long. Or that the 40-pound dog I owned for 10 years now weighs too much to live with me. Buy a condo or a co-op, and you could be [the] one who ends up owned."


Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.