Is it rude to ask someone whether they rent or own? Or just obsolete?

Share this Article

Holiday Tipping Poll
Holiday Tipping Poll
How much do you plan to tip the building staff this year?

For a New Yorker, asking whether someone rents or owns is pretty standard conversational fare, at least whenever the topic turns to real estate.  But apparently we're a little out of touch with the rest of the country.

"When I first moved to NYC, I used to be shocked at how directly strangers try to deduce each other's income," notes one apartment dweller on an thread debating the propriety of the rent-or-own inquisition. "'What do you do? Do you rent or own? What building?' I guess I'm used to it now."

Another wonders:  "Is it spite? is it competition? is it to figure out how much the other people make?"--raising the question of whether it's shameful to say that you rent. Yes, says one: "Renters tend to live hand to mouth...for MOST people, it's not a lifestyle choice.  (Response: "Many, many people who are unbelievably wealthy rent apartments in this city. I think you are taking this all way too personally...they are just making small talk.")

Several commenters point out that technology has provided an alternative outlet for ownshership-status quests once you have an address in hand.

"I used to people," confesses one, explaining she used to look up ex-boyfriends and old friends to see who was getting married. A bit older and more real estate obsessed now, "I them. Not proud, just what I do." (