Buy Curious

Is Sheepshead Bay Brooklyn's next big neighborhood?

By Leah Hochbaum Rosner  | February 17, 2016 - 8:59AM

Curious which of Brooklyn’s previously unsung neighborhoods will soon be the borough’s next big thing? Those in the know say it may be Sheepshead Bay. Erin Keane of Kings and Queens tells you why the reasonably-priced waterfront region might soon be all the rage in this week’s Buy Curious.


I just read that the tallest tower in Sheepshead Bay  is being built and is going  to bring a lot of new residential space to this area. I'm curious about the neighborhood and wondering, do you think Sheepshead Bay could be Brooklyn’s next-up-and-coming neighborhood?


The proposed 331-foot, 30-story glass-and-steel tower at 1501 Voorhies Avenue will bring 232 residential units—both rentals and condos—as well as an additional 15,000 square feet of commercial space to Sheepshead Bay, a middle-class neighborhood in southern Brooklyn whose strange name derives from the sheepshead—a fish whose face and teeth are said to look like those of a sheep, which used to be plentiful in the bay’s waters.

The structure will definitely stand out, says Keane, since “Sheepshead Bay housing is mainly comprised of six-and seven-story apartment buildings, low-rise brick row houses, as well as large individually-owned houses.”

But the new building isn’t the only thing that’s changing in the area, which, long known for its Russian/Eastern European community, is now becoming much more diverse. According to Keane, there’s recently been an influx of new residents from Astoria, Queens, as well as other, costlier neighborhoods in Brooklyn, such as Park Slope. “Since [prices] have increased at a faster pace, [people] are now venturing further south to Sheepshead Bay,” she says.

In fact, according to StreetEasy, the median price for a one-bedroom condo in Sheepshead Bay is $489,500, while the median price for the same in Astoria is $620,000 and in Park Slope is $699,000.

“Typically, people who move to Sheepshead Bay are looking to save money… or because they can no longer afford to live where they were before,” says Keane, referring to higher-priced locales like the aforementioned Astoria and Park Slope. Other recent clients of Keane who settled in Sheepshead Bay have hailed from New Jersey and upstate New York, and made the move to be closer to work, she says.   

“I have also noticed that clients are moving here for a better quality of life—meaning the area is less crowded than many other similarly priced regions in NYC, and there’s a lovely waterfront space to enjoy—“even if the flipside is a longer commute.” Although lengthier, daily travel to Manhattan is still rather painless from the region, what with two subway lines (the B and Q) and an express bus (the BM3) that run into Manhattan regularly. It takes about an hour to get to midtown by train. The bus ride is a little longer. And “for those who prefer to drive, there is easy access to the Belt Parkway,” she says. 

Keane has also observed that of the couples with young children moving to Sheepshead Bay, many actually grew up in the area themselves and are coming back to “be closer to their families for support, and also so their children may experience and learn the heritage and culture of their parents.”

“The neighborhood’s shops and restaurants along [main thoroughfares] Emmons Avenue and Sheepshead Bay Road are reflective of its growing diversity,” says Keane. Restaurants span from famous retro fast food joint Roll-N-Roaster to Randazzo’s Clam Bar, an Italian Seafood restaurant, to OPera Café & Lounge, a Turkish eatery, to Chayhana Salom, which serves authentic Uzbek food, to Yiasou Estiatorio, which specializes in Greek seafood. For grocery stores, there’s a large Stop & Shop supermarket in the area, as well as a few health food store options, including Forces of Nature and Omni Health.

Besides more affordable living spaces and lots of places to eat, the “appealing and quiet” neighborhood, according to Keane, “offers great quality of living, with access to the waterfront and open spaces,” including Holocaust Memorial Park, at the western end of the bay, which hosts commemorative events throughout the year. Fishing boats galore dock in the bay daily and offer commercial fishing trips, as well as dinner and charter cruises. Locals and visitors can often be found perched on the benches that surround the water watching the vessels go by, or just feeding the ducks.

“Sheepshead Bay has seen a lot of changes over the years ,” says Keane. In fact, the region used to be known as the place to go to purchase fresh fish; now, while fishing is still a popular activity, it's usually more for sport than survival. Additionally, after After Hurricane Sandy—which devastated the region when floodwaters flowed over the bay, destroying many of the businesses in its wake—some retailers were able to bounce back, while others were forced to close their doors. “Over the next couple of years, we will see an increase in residential and commercial developments, which will hopefully revive the retail market.”

Keane thinks that the new high-rise tower will “encourage commercial and residential development in the neighborhood. It will also provide a luxury product attracting a different type of clientele.” And “with the increased development and everything that Sheepshead Bay has to offer, it is on its way to being the next up-and-coming neighborhood.”

However, not everyone thinks the new tower will be a welcome addition to the neighborhood. Sheepshead Bites, a news site that covers the area, called the very idea of the building “bonkers” and wrote that: “Residents and community leaders have expressed concern the tower could disrupt the neighborhood’s parking, traffic and sewer infrastructure.”

Here are some places up for grabs in Sheepshead Bay right now:

Sheepshead Bay two-bedroom, two-bathroom co-op, $299,900: Located at 3203 Nostrand Avenue, between Avenue R and Avenue S, this remodeled two-bedroom co-op has an eat-in kitchen with granite countertops, a separate dining area, and two large bedrooms with six closets, including one walk-in. The co-op building has new elevators, newly landscaped garden and patio areas, a live-in super, bike storage and a parking garage.

Sheepshead Bay three-bedroom, three-bathroom townhouse, $829,000: This brick townhouse at 2566 East 14th Street, between Avenue Y and Avenue Z, has more than 2,000 square feet of living space. There are hardwood floors, a modern kitchen and dining area, a basement with a separate entrance, and a garden with fruit trees.

Sheepshead Bay five-bedroom, two-bathroom house, $795,000: This two-unit home at 1757 East 24th Street, between Avenue R and Quentin Road, is an estate sale and is being sold as is. The first-floor of the home has a large living area, an open eat-in kitchen, two large bedrooms, and a bonus room that can be used as a bedroom, a playroom or an office. The bottom floor also offers two-bedrooms and an eat-in kitchen. There’s a two-car garage.

Sheepshead Bay three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bathroom condo, $1.15 million: The elevator opens directly into this newly constructed three-bedroom condo unit located at 1702 Avenue Z,  between East 17th and East 18th Streets. It offers two terraces with planters, a utility closet with a washer and dryer, and a walk-in closet in the master bedroom.  

Sheepshead Bay three-bedroom, two-bathroom condo, $699,000: This 1,620-square-foot condo at 2844 Ford Street, between Emmons Avenue and Shore Parkway, has an in-unit laundry, a patio and a carport. The kitchen has granite countertops and stainless steel appliances, including a dishwasher. 


The 8 best NYC neighborhoods for first-time buyers

Brick Underground articles occasionally include the expertise of, or information about, advertising partners when relevant to the story. We will never promote an advertiser's product without making the relationship clear to our readers.